Laurent Nkunda: The Other Side of the Story
I was completely surprised upon meeting National Congress for the
Defense of the People (CNDP) General Laurent Nkunda that his first
words to me were to describe me as a “nature writer” who was in Congo
to protect the gorillas. The General had obviously done his homework on
me, but had no clue as to my personal and moral evolution regarding
humanitarian issues in DRC since 2007.
Western media has
fabricated an image of Nkunda as an eccentric warlord and murderer who
is to be despised and feared. Nkunda is a military leader and military
men kill. Nkunda admits that war has its consequences. Every army in
the history of humankind has been responsible for atrocities, and
citizens of the United States need look no further than Abu Ghraib. Who
is ultimately to be blamed?
An underground resistance movement
arranged the interview with Nkunda. This movement is not populated with
wild-eyed freedom fighters, but rather by serious professionals and
government officials who believe that Nkunda offers the possibility of
hope and change for a country riddled with corruption.
Aussie
journalist Helen Thomas, an American medical doctor and a former member
of the RPF army, joined me in entering rebel controlled territory. The
most difficult and stressful part of our entry was a Ugandan border
check where an inebriated Ugandan official demanded $50 each to
guarantee our “safety.” After much arguing and discussion, a call came
from “Chairman” Nkunda that we were his guests and should be allowed to
pass the short distance to the Congolese border, where we were met by
well-trained and disciplined officers of the CNDP army. This was
obviously no rag- tag group of freedom fighters. CNDP “Captain Sahara”
met us with a polite “bon jour” and assisted our crossing into Nkunda’s
21,000 square kilometers of territory.
Entering the rebel
stronghold was far less intimidating than entering the United States
Coast Guard monitoring station at Carrollton Avenue in New Orleans,
Louisiana.
At no time while under Nkunda’s rule did we feel
frightened or threatened. On the contrary, I can say that I am
absolutely terrified of the regular Congolese army (FARDC), which
controls Goma and points north and west. This is not an investigative
report, but suffice it to say that we received many instances of
personal testimony describing harassment and shootings by the FARDC. A
human rights worker told how the windows of his aid vehicle were shot
out by a uniformed FARDC solder riding a motorcycle on the pulverized
tarmac that passes as a “road” through the spine of Virunga Park. The
same aid worker said he felt safe while crossing into CNDP held
territory.
Refugees related stories of being chased from their
homes by “soldiers,” but could seldom identify which army. In one
instance in FARDC territory north of Goma a woman said she was “chased
by Mai Mai,” and in one other instance a woman said she was “told” that
it was the CNDP that attacked her village, but that she “never saw
them.”
Congolese president Joseph Kabila rules through
intimidation and fear. His army (FARDC) is undisciplined and guilty of
many more atrocities than the allegations leveled against Nkunda.
Kabila is clearly exploiting the wealth of Congo as much or more than
Mobutu did, yet Western interests, including the United States support
him. Dan Rather recently did an excellent report “All Mine,” which is
available for $.99 on iTunes.
Human Rights Watch has also condemned the suppression of free speech in DRC under Kabila. (
reference)
We
have heard again and again that Kabila owns homes all over the world,
including a mansion in Malibu, California. Instead of persecuting
Nkunda, perhaps the New York Times might want to do an investigative
report on this.
In CNDP held territory, villagers were in
extreme poverty by Western standards, but had gardens, pigs in the
yard, flowers growing, and they happily waved and shouted as we drove
along the road cut by Nkunda’s army. Villagers were engaging and
offered none of the blank, sullen stares or frightened responses one
gets in FARDC controlled sectors.
As far as Nkunda is concerned,
human rights groups will have fits of apoplexy as I report that he was
completely appropriate in demeanor. I cannot judge the man, but the
medical doctor who was with us remarked that Nkunda exhibited no
grandiose, narcissistic or paranoid traits. He is certainly charismatic
and one must always be on guard when in the presence of charisma, but
my impression of Nkunda is that he is a man who has dedicated his life
toward the liberation of Congo from foreign interests, graft and
corruption.
Nkunda was surprised when I told him about the
distorted photos that accompany articles about him in the Western
media. Weird angles, harsh shadows and imaginative prose by writers
intent upon furthering writing careers, rather than journalism, have
dominated the New York Times and other western print media.
Nkunda
was courteous, engaging and welcoming. As the dirt floor flooded during
the course of our interview, Nkunda became concerned for our gear and
equipment. This was hardly the reaction one would expect from an
imperious warlord. Was it a snow job? I doubt it. He seems serious
about reaching out to Western interests. And I am not ashamed to say
that I enjoyed our informal conversations after the interview. Why?
Because I found a human connection that involved serious concern for
the people of Congo.
I shared dinner with the man as an intense
Virunga thunderstorm raged outside of the open-sided rondeval with a
shredded tarp from UNICEF providing the only buffer from the wind. We
talked politics, family life, and shared a pleasant conversation..
Eating dinner with the general (photo by G. Nienaber)I
am ashamed to know that some American journalists who provide reports
that shape world opinion have been too frightened to enter Congo to see
with their own eyes and hear with their own ears.
It was
horrible to learn from sources in Rwanda that a noted US reporter was
terrified to meet with Nkunda. Instead, he paid for information,
instead of accepting an invitation for an interview as we did.
Journalists
should be witnesses. We should tell the story. We can use our gift of
turning thoughts into words to describe the conditions we encounter in
the world. Let the politicians and think tanks determine policy. If we
are able to present a clear picture, perhaps the politicians will be
forced to act in the name of humanity.
What should I say when a
member of the resistance comes to me and asks with tears in his eyes,
“Why won’t journalists tell the truth?” I heard the phrase “we are
crying,” many times from Congolese.
We were invited back to
visit at any time. And Nkunda had a request. Would I try to bring a
Congolese American to visit with him?
Then, there was the final
question. Would the new Obama government listen to what we reported
with an open mind for the Congolese? I replied that I was very small
but that I would shout in a loud voice on behalf of the Congolese
people. I also told him that I did not know how I would do this.
Nkunda
told me, and I will never forget this, “Don’t worry about what you will
do. You are “doing” now. By coming here, by speaking on behalf of the
Congolese people when you write about the conditions in Goma and in the
camps, by speaking openly about this, you are doing. You are doing.”
*********
TIMELINE:January
3, 2009: Australian Journalist Helen Thomas and I meet with General
Laurent Nkunda in occupied territory. We spend over six hours with him.
Nothing seems unusual in terms of stress or concern on the part of his
troops. Peace talks are scheduled to begin in four days in Nairobi. The
CNDP Commissioner of Foreign Affairs, Rene Abandi, joins us for
discussion. Abandi is scheduled to be at the peace talks.
January
5, 2009: While in Goma, rumors begin to surface that Nkunda has been
removed from power of the CNDP. Sources from within the CNDP tell us
this is not true. We wait.
Western mainstream media picks up a
consistent drumbeat castigating Nkunda. The stories originate in Dakar,
and Kinshasa. No one is reporting this from our location.
January 12, 2009: Posting from Dakar, Senegal, the
New York Times said, "Disagreements over tactics and power have split the once seemingly invincible Congolese (CNDP)."
Nkunda vehemently denied the NYT article in a phone interview with us.
One
thing is clear. The Congolese Regular Army (FARDC), under President
Joseph Kabila, attacked the CNDP in August 2008, and quickly lost
ground despite superior numbers. The attack shattered a tentative peace
agreement. The NYT account supports BBC reports that Nkunda is fighting
off an attempt to topple him by CNDP faction leader Jean Bosco Ntaganda.
"This is absolutely not true," Nkunda said from his location in north Kivu Province in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).
Nkunda
said that Ntaganda was "unable to move more than one kilometer from his
home," and was surrounded by CNDP forces. Nkunda estimated that
Ntaganda had "as few as 36 soldiers" with him.
January 19:
Rwanda announces a “joint operation” with DRCongo that has been agreed
upon since December 2008 in which troops will attempt to disarm
remnants of the Interahamwe in eastern Congo. Leaders of the FDLR are
responsible for the genocide of 1994. Nkunda has said all along he is
protecting his people from attacks by the FDLR.
Thomas and I are no longer in country and must rely upon emails and phone conversations with sources on ground in Congo.
One
source close to the CNDP described a meeting which took place in
Gisenyi, Rwanda in which the CNDP, Ntaganda, Congolese General Numbi
and “others Rwandese and Congolese staff were invited.”
“In that
meeting the chief of Staff of Rwanda told our high commander that there
was a plan and they must be part of it and for that they must accept
Ntaganda as their chief of staff. It was an order and it wasn't
negotiable. And they said that General Nkunda must be removed as the
chairman of CNDP and that they won't deal with him.
“Of course
our high commander refused at first to sign the document which was
already prepared, but the Chairman (Nkunda) told them to sign and they
did so.
“The chairman is in danger because he has an army which
is loyal to him and as long as he is around the plan can't be carried
out as they want.”
Apparently there was a deal between DRC and Rwanda that no one in the Western media has reported.
Sources
say Rwanda assured Kabila that Rwanda was capable of destroying Nkunda.
They tried to accomplish this by installing Ntaganda as head of the
CNDP, but the plan fell apart when the CNDP army remained loyal to
Nkunda.
Sources say Ntaganda was given $250,000 and promise of amnesty from his indictment by The Hague for war crimes.
Rwanda sends 3000 soldiers into DRC.
Another source, not connected to the CNDP, described the situation.
“In all honesty, I just don't know what is happening at the moment, and I suspect it wasn't exactly planned.
“Like so many things over here, it's basically quite messy.
“I
think Nkunda has taken a slight hit, because he was not able to quell
Bosco's (Ntaganda’s) insubordination, but as far as I can tell, he is
still very much in the driving seat of CNDP, but he's obviously going
to have to make some compromises if the Rwandan and Congolese
governments are behind Bosco's initiative.
“It was reported
that MONUC have been blocked out of Rutshuru, but that's not actually
true. For now everything is very calm, but we're bracing ourselves. A
major coalition assault on the FDLR may well be in the pipeline, but I
can't believe they'll actually succeed in bringing them in.
“We're
quite worried about the consequences, in terms of insecurity, but at a
very superficial level, I can't help hoping that something good may
come of the fact that CNDP, FARDC and RPF are together, if it means the
fighting will stop and the IDPs can return to their homes without
getting attacked.”
January 23, 2009: From source close to Nkunda:
“I
know you've heard the news that the Chairman has been arrested, that is
not the truth but he came by himself to Gisenyi last night to meet the
Chief of staff of Rwanda. He is at Gisenyi in a hotel but anything can
happen. Although the option of arresting him will be a huge mistake
because there will be a terrible fight between CNDP and RDF and FARC. “
Inside a Congolese IDP Camp